Retirement Spending and Asset Withdrawals
The whole exercise lives on one timeline: your future spending, your other income, and the assets you can actually draw on. Start with the yearly shortfall, then ask whether the portfolio can support withdrawals year after year.
From Spending to a Target Number
Your annual withdrawal need is simple: total annual spending minus whatever other net income is available that same year. Use income available for spending after its associated costs.
Total spending covers daily costs, the occasional big one-off, and the tax cost of withdrawals themselves. Keep the house you're holding onto in a separate column from the financial portfolio, and count cash reserves once, not twice if they're already inside the portfolio.
Work backwards from a withdrawal. If you need 80,000 yuan a year, the starting balance that funds it depends on the rate you choose:
- 3% means about 2.67 million yuan
- 4% means 2 million yuan
- 5% means 1.6 million yuan
These are teaching numbers, there to show how much the target moves when you change one assumption. A real plan has more inputs: how many years you're drawing for, what the portfolio holds, how spending is expected to change, and how much slack you'll allow yourself.
Two Ways to Take Money Out
Fixed real spending: take 80,000 yuan in year one, and if the cost of living rises 3%, take 82,400 the next year. Purchasing power stays roughly constant, and the account eats the market's ups and downs. Long weak stretches thin the balance even though your spending never changed.
Percentage of balance: take 4% of whatever the portfolio holds at the moment. When the balance falls from 2 million to 1.5 million, your withdrawal drops from 80,000 to 60,000 in the same move. Spending follows the money, which only works if your budget can flex.
This is why it helps to split spending into must-haves (rent, food, insurance) and can-wait items, so you can judge whether trimming is even possible. Log pensions and side jobs with their start and end dates, and compute the gap both before and after each one kicks in.
Why Return Order Matters
A teaching example: start from 1 million yuan, apply that year's return first, then withdraw 100,000 yuan at year-end. Taxes and inflation are ignored.
| Return order | After year one's withdrawal | After year two's withdrawal |
|---|---|---|
| up 20%, then down 20% | 1.1 million yuan | 780,000 yuan |
| down 20%, then up 20% | 700,000 yuan | 740,000 yuan |
Leave withdrawals out and both paths end at 960,000. With withdrawals, taking money out after an early loss leaves a smaller base to participate in a later recovery. That is the reason the withdrawal phase deserves its own study of return order.
Dividends and Sales Are One Bucket
Count both dividends spent on living costs and proceeds withdrawn from asset sales in the total cash taken out of the portfolio. On a 2 million yuan base, spending 1.2% in dividends and selling off 3% for living adds up to 84,000 yuan, a 4.2% total draw.
If a fund's total return already includes dividends, adding the dividend income on top of the growth rate double-counts it. Dividends retained and reinvested stay within the portfolio and participate in its subsequent gains or losses. On how withdrawal records relate to net asset value, see Fund Net Asset Value and Personal Investment Returns.
Review the Plan Regularly
Update it every year: actual spending, other net income, current balance, the remaining planning horizon. Then check where adjustments would actually land, which line items shrink, which get postponed. Stress-test with paths that include an early drawdown and high prices, and note the year the money runs out. Fixing a shortfall might mean starting later, spending less, or lining up more income.
If your early retirement plan stretches past thirty years, don't inherit someone else's horizon. Recompute for your own.
On purchasing power, see Compounding, Fees, and Real Purchasing Power; for near-term liquidity, Income Concentration and Cash Reserves. The full worked calculation is in How to figure out how much you need to retire early, and the topic hub is Turning investment returns into actual gains.